Let's Talk BBQ

Recipes => Recipes => Pork Recipes => Topic started by: Smokin Don on March 24, 2014, 01:01:07 PM

Title: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Smokin Don on March 24, 2014, 01:01:07 PM
Mar 23 2014

I am like a kid with a toy, some recipes I see and know I just have to try it. This was one of those I found on Food52 by ENunn. The ingredients, maple syrup, a lot of garlic, fennel seeds, black pepper and cayenne sounded good. To top it off at the end you were to baste it with a bottle of Matilda beer, a malt fruity taste. It was for a 6 to 8 lb. pork shoulder with skin on, scored. Cooking time was 18 hours at 225 deg. in an inside oven. I adapted it to my Traeger pellet smoker.

I knew I would have to use a fresh picnic shoulder, the only skin on pork I can get around here. I could not find Matilda beer, made by Goose Island. I bought some Leinenkugels Berry Weis. It sure is fruity and ended up mixing it with half Leiny’s Hoppin Helles.

My picnic shoulder was 9.3 lbs. I trimmed about an inch of the fat off 3 sides and scored it an inch wide. I used a utility knife to get through the skin then a boning knife to cut down to the meat. I had mixed my maple syrup, olive oil, and malt vinegar and mixed my garlic paste up. Rereading the directions I saw I was supposed to add the olive oil to the garlic paste. I thought oh well it’s all going on anyways. I added some onions to the pan for flavor.

I was doing the pork in two foil roasters, makes it easier to carry and the bottom pan I could use again. I smeared 1/3 of the garlic paste over the meat side and in the roaster pan fat side down I had sprayed with olive oil. It went into a 410 deg. oven for 30 minutes. The recipe said 450 deg. but I was afraid the fat would stick when I turned it to skin side up. I used some meat gloves to turn the roast and didn’t get that much brown but figured to do at the end of the cook.

I poured about a third of the maple syrup mix over it then smeared on the rest of the garlic paste. I saved the rest of the syrup mix and basted it twice during the night and through the next morning. It went on my Traeger preheated to 225 deg. this was at 11:00 pm Sat. night. I am a little leery about doing a cook over night since my smoker is on a wood deck but at that low of temperature and with my Maverick high temp alarm set to 300 deg. I felt pretty safe.

I got up twice during the night to baste it and check on the pellets. I was using Cookin Pellets 100% hickory. I kept an eye on it all day Sunday, and got the syrup mix all on. I started basting it with the beer about 3:00.

I checked the temp at 4:15 and it was 180 deg. IT so I heated up my oven to 450 deg. to crisp up the skin. It took 15 min. to crisp the skin. I turned the oven off and left the door ajar for 10 minutes. I took it out and let set 10 minutes. Using my meat gloves I placed it on a large tray and let set another 15 minutes.
I pulled enough for my supper. I only got about half the skin crisp enough to eat but was great.

I had some Bush’s Grillin beans, southern pit style, and some bread and butter. I had some Cholula hot sauce, the pork was sweet so the heat was good on it. I was eating all alone, all that good pork! Our son had to work. My wife was at a play with a friend. My wife and daughter in law was going to get pizza at 6 but the wife was late getting home and the daughter in law didn’t get here until 6:30 and had already ate.

I had a plate fixed up for my son to pick up and share at work. My daughter in law ran it up to him. The grandson was at a neighbors playing so when the daughter in law went to pick him up I sent some of the pork for the neighbors.

Would I do it again, yes, it was as tender and moist as any pork roast I have done. I loved the flavors but would do it at 250 to 275 deg. to shorten the cooking time. I might cut back some on the fennel and would mix the olive oil with the garlic paste and do the maple syrup mix the same way as I did. Pouring all that syrup on at once would just run off and maybe burn in the pan.

A little long winded but it was along cook!

Note: Changes I would do, use cumin seeds instead of fennel, start with 1 Tbs. add 1/4 malt vinegar, and 2 tsp. cayenne pepper. I think the cumin would pair better with the sweet and heat and there is enough sweet to use some extra sour.

Link to recipe: http://food52.com/recipes/3909-matilda-maple-garlic-pork-shoulder-with-crispy-skin

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221497_zpsf4889953.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221499_zps8b16cdb2.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221501_zpse5513ddc.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221502_zps95efb8d1.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221503_zps65ef09a1.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221504_zpsbbdcc14c.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221505_zps4c41b354.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3221506_zpsd9cf28e0.jpg)

6 hours in
(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3231507_zpse1b8f1ce.jpg)

12 hours in
(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3231508_zps1fd377ca.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3231510_zps38f5f817.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3231517_zps5182ac11.jpg)

(http://i1039.photobucket.com/albums/a474/deains/Traeger%20Food%202014/_3231518_zps530139f9.jpg)

Smokin Don
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: CDN Smoker on March 24, 2014, 01:27:05 PM
Man-O-Man SD your killing us with these fantastic cooks ;D

I really like when you adapt recipes to the smoker
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: TMB on March 24, 2014, 01:52:04 PM
WOW that looks good, I'll send you my addy so you can send some to me  ;) ;) ;) ;)
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Don O on March 24, 2014, 01:54:42 PM
Man oh man SD, I don't how you keep doing all these wonderful recipes, but keep it up.
Thanks for your efforts.
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: sliding_billy on March 24, 2014, 03:50:16 PM
Looks great.  Glad to see you able to get back "outside."
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: HighOnSmoke on March 24, 2014, 04:31:24 PM
Fantastic Don! A must try recipe for me! Bookmarked!
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Ka Honu on March 24, 2014, 04:33:00 PM
...I only got about half the skin crisp enough to eat but was great...

I have trouble with that part too and I've tried damn near every combination there is of hi-low temp, poking holes in the skin, rotating the roast, wiping off some of the seasoning, etc., etc., etc. I think it may have something to do with the skin not being dry enough because of the rub/seasoning and because some of it is below center which allow drippings from the roast above.  One solution is to remove the skin while the roast is resting and crisp it on a baking sheet, then serve it with the rest.

Other than that one relatively minor irritant, your shoulder looks like a total winner.
Title: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Pappymn on March 24, 2014, 04:53:06 PM
That is some beautiful looking poke SD!
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Saber 4 on March 24, 2014, 08:30:10 PM
That looks great, I would definitely give this one a shot in the Bradley with a finish in the SRG.
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Smokin Don on March 24, 2014, 09:09:34 PM
...I only got about half the skin crisp enough to eat but was great...

I think it may have something to do with the skin not being dry enough because of the rub/seasoning and because some of it is below center which allow drippings from the roast above.  One solution is to remove the skin while the roast is resting and crisp it on a baking sheet, then serve it with the rest.

Other than that one relatively minor irritant, your shoulder looks like a total winner.


I think you hit it on the head, what did not get crisp was in the middle and low. Maybe under the broiler would work. The broiler is tricky though goes from crisp to burnt in a few seconds. I need to take another look at the one you posted I remember it looked pretty darn good. Savanah Smoker has done some too that looked good. Don
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: Saber 4 on March 24, 2014, 10:42:11 PM
...I only got about half the skin crisp enough to eat but was great...

I think it may have something to do with the skin not being dry enough because of the rub/seasoning and because some of it is below center which allow drippings from the roast above.  One solution is to remove the skin while the roast is resting and crisp it on a baking sheet, then serve it with the rest.

Other than that one relatively minor irritant, your shoulder looks like a total winner.


I think you hit it on the head, what did not get crisp was in the middle and low. Maybe under the broiler would work. The broiler is tricky though goes from crisp to burnt in a few seconds. I need to take another look at the one you posted I remember it looked pretty darn good. Savanah Smoker has done some too that looked good. Don

I've used a propane torch to melt and bubble harder cheeses on burgers before, I wonder if it would crisp up your skin for you without going to burnt like the broiler?
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: muebe on March 25, 2014, 07:10:29 AM
Beautiful Don!!!
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: africanmeat on March 25, 2014, 09:34:42 AM
It looks amazing . i will love eating a plate like that.
Title: Re: Maple Garlic Pork Shoulder w/crispy skin
Post by: pz on March 25, 2014, 04:42:17 PM
That's a real winner, Don!